Kpop as Art, Kpop as Industry
Nov. 6th, 2026 06:20 pmI had convinced myself not to write this essay because, let's be real, who really needed my two cents on a fandom I have mostly divorced myself from, as the music that drew me in is not being made that often now, and the prevalence of extreme eating disorders grew more triggering. However, with the NYT bombshell about the New Jeans' contracts, I do feel like this is a conversation to be had. So, I suppose, let us start.
Kpop is an industry. Not music.
I came to kpop like many did, sweating from every pore during 2020. It was Colorado's then-hottest summer, I had recently been pandemic laid off, and I had nothing good in my life, not even air conditioning. BTS was skyrocketing up the Billboard charts with their smash hit "Dynamite" which I still consider a little bop. I had several fandom friends who were already into kpop, making it easy to fall down the rabbit hole.
While I did enjoy my time with BTS, the first group I truly fell in love with was WayV. For those who don't know, WayV is the "Chinese unit" of NCT. They were founded explicitly to increase SM's footprint in China, and as such most of their songs are in Chinese.
People liked to call WayV "cpop" or "mando pop" as if it was the language they sang that defined their genre. Meanwhile, they lived, worked and were managed in Korea. They participated in music shows and joined NCT group activities (NCT being, indisputably, a kpop group). In fact, their title track from Awaken the World, "Turn Back Time" has both a Chinese-language and Korean-language version.
Was I supposed to consider the former cpop and the latter kpop? When I saw Purple Kiss in concert for their first US tour, they sang several English versions of their most popular songs. Were those just "pop"?
If language is a key requirement to genre, how can a classical music fan tell the difference between a military march and a divertimento?
If nationality is what's required to create kpop, why is Dem Jointz, a black American, one of the best kpop producers of all time?
When you ask kpop fans what makes kpop great, the answers usually include things like "the music is catchy", "the performances are high energy" and "the dancing is next level". Only one of those has anything to do with genre at all, and it could easily describe pop music in any language.
Unfortunately, I cannot find the tweet that I titled this section after so if anyone sees one to that effect, please send it to me so I can credit it.
This is the part of the essay where I directly contradict myself. Because my mysterious twitter user was entirely correct. While kpop does clearly draw inspiration from western pop, rock, hip hop, and R&B, if that was all it did, why did One Direction sound so different from Shinee? In fact, there's only one western pop group I can say even comes close to the kpop sounds of that era: N*SYNC.
Kpop is a genre, however it is not because they (sometimes) sing in Korean. Like every other genre, it is defined by the actual music.
One of the main reasons I delayed writing this essay was because my initial thoughts were driven by haterism. Even I find myself insufferable as fuck when I'm being bitter hater, so I try to discourage these tendencies within myself. Fortunately, in between then and now, a group I adore dropped an album illustrating my point exactly.
Just B's "Chest" and the album "Just Odd" were on my Top of 2025 lists. However by their own admission, "Chest" was them bringing hyperpop into the kpop scene. Their follow up title, "True Heart" was similarly hyper pop. Fantastic songs, but not kpop.
While they seem to have gone out of vogue, I can't be the only one who remembers press releases describing the songs to be released. They'd say things like "R&B ballad that expresses the true feelings of the members" and other very corny things. It seems only the fans were unaware that not every pop song that came out of Korea was kpop-the-genre.
So what is kpop music?
What drew me in, aside from WayV's princess party, was kpop's ability to combine genres in unexpected, new ways in a single song, while also playing fast and loose with song structure.
Before 2020, I had never heard anything like "Lucifer" or "I Got a Boy". It's easy to say "Well, that's just SM" but that's reductive. Lee Soo Man was a pioneer in the genre, true, but these traits show up across the industry, in 2NE1, Big Bang, Oh My Girl, EXID, and in more contemporary groups like i-dle, Dreamcatcher, NMIXX and, yes, Just B.
Just B's "K-pop" (the album) is truly an evolutionary homage to this sound. It could have been penned by GD himself, if not for the shades of hyperpop and undeniable Just B indie attitude woven throughout.
If this is the sound you like—kpop as a blender, far more experimental than the pop that charts in the US and UK—it isn't strange to find yourself divorced from the current crop of kpop darlings. There has been an industry-wide shift to chasing global (read: American) dollars and a shift from traditional promotion towards hoping to go viral on tiktok. Whether or not these are the decisions of A&R teams or edicts handed down by CEOs, the elements of kpop (the genre) have been almost wholly abandoned in 5th gen. Many of the darlings of the charts make straight bubblegum pop or songs that wouldn't stand out on a Travis Scott album. This doesn't make them bad songs, but it's ludicrous to pretend they're the same genre as "Sticker".
Yes, you can still find some amazing genre-bending bangers, like Close Your Eyes' "Open Your Eyes" and All Hours' "Dang Dang" but they have become rare. Like everything, kpop will continue moving forward whether it wants to or not, and as kpop-the-genre fades into the background, most of what we now associate as its hallmarks are actually kpop-the-industry standards and practices.
What the heck does any of this have to do with New Jeans? Well, I can't think of a better example of a group exposing the realities of kpop (the industry) since TVXQ.
These were very young girls who were coerced into signing contracts that shocked even American record execs working in the 1970s, who were beaten down, shunned, told to have plastic surgery, and still managed to become global sensations, all while singing about their pussies. At 14. And yes. That is what "Cookie" is about.
They had the perfect, innocent looks to bait the pedophiles and mom-fans, the creative direction of the canny Min Hee Jin who saw a gap in the market to bring parasocialism to an even younger crowd, all backed by the money and machinery of HYBE.
And the worst thing is that kpop fans haven't seemed to learn shit all from the whole fiasco.
Lee Soo Man's new A20 groups are the direct result of an industry that has only became more exploitative. I genuinely believe it should be a crime to debut 13-year-olds.
Not a single actor, idol, singer, or other entertainer who worked on a professional level as a child says it was good for them. In fact, Taliesin Jaffe and Ashley Johnson, now of Critical Role fame, have an entire podcast about their fucked-up childhoods as kid TV stars. In one episode, Ashley recalls how she was almost kidnapped on set by a stalker fan.
We already know kpop has a sasaeng problem, but it's totally fine to put 13-year-olds in danger because the music's good, right?
Idols work as hard as professional athletes. According to the New York Times article, pre-debut, when some of them were as young as 12, New Jeans was practicing until 2 AM. Should any 12-year-old be going to school during the day, and then dancing without breaks until the early morning? Not only can this cause massive psychological damage, but it also literally changes how your body grows. SNSD have talked about how they didn't get their periods until years after their non-idol peers.
But who cares because look at them dance!
No one wants to confront the reality written so clearly in the New Jeans contract: it is preferable to debut children because they don't have the means to protect themselves. And any parent that would willingly put their child in that situation clearly does not care about protecting them either.
A20 is the inevitable conclusion of kpop-the-industry. Just like every other capitalist endeavor, it must extract greater and greater profit to satisfy the rich, and the best way to do this is by increasing the exploitation of the laborers and jacking up the prices on the consumers.
So, that was bleak and I don't like ending on a down note. However we can't get from point A to point B if we refuse to acknowledge where point A actually is.
It is really down to the individual fan to decide how they want to react to this information. Much like some have refused to put down Harry Potter because it meant so much to them as children, even though any money spent on the HP empire goes to fund anti-trans legislation, some kpop fans simply will not give a shit if buying albums and merch and fancalls for a group hurts the very people they claim to support.
I strongly believe we owe responsibilities to others, and in the dynamic of fan-versus-corporation, that responsibility looks very different than individual-to-community. It is your responsibility to choose where you spend your entertainment dollars. I mentioned at the beginning of this essay that WayV stole my heart. They broke it, too, with the news that YangYang directly profits from Israel's genocide in Gaza through owning shares in his family company.
I had to choose. What was more important to me: a group that brought me so much happiness or standing in solidarity with Palestine?
It is good to ask yourselves these questions, even if it means you are too sad to listen to a discography you loved. It's not like WayV is the only kpop group I enjoy. I've found new ones, and other things that bring me joy beside. And I feel peace, because I don't have the guilt weighing on my conscience.
Let me assure you, that as a millennial, I've watched many industries die, yet art always lives on.
Kpop is an industry. Not music.
"Korean" is not a genre.
I came to kpop like many did, sweating from every pore during 2020. It was Colorado's then-hottest summer, I had recently been pandemic laid off, and I had nothing good in my life, not even air conditioning. BTS was skyrocketing up the Billboard charts with their smash hit "Dynamite" which I still consider a little bop. I had several fandom friends who were already into kpop, making it easy to fall down the rabbit hole.
While I did enjoy my time with BTS, the first group I truly fell in love with was WayV. For those who don't know, WayV is the "Chinese unit" of NCT. They were founded explicitly to increase SM's footprint in China, and as such most of their songs are in Chinese.
People liked to call WayV "cpop" or "mando pop" as if it was the language they sang that defined their genre. Meanwhile, they lived, worked and were managed in Korea. They participated in music shows and joined NCT group activities (NCT being, indisputably, a kpop group). In fact, their title track from Awaken the World, "Turn Back Time" has both a Chinese-language and Korean-language version.
Was I supposed to consider the former cpop and the latter kpop? When I saw Purple Kiss in concert for their first US tour, they sang several English versions of their most popular songs. Were those just "pop"?
If language is a key requirement to genre, how can a classical music fan tell the difference between a military march and a divertimento?
If nationality is what's required to create kpop, why is Dem Jointz, a black American, one of the best kpop producers of all time?
When you ask kpop fans what makes kpop great, the answers usually include things like "the music is catchy", "the performances are high energy" and "the dancing is next level". Only one of those has anything to do with genre at all, and it could easily describe pop music in any language.
No American Super Junior
Unfortunately, I cannot find the tweet that I titled this section after so if anyone sees one to that effect, please send it to me so I can credit it.
This is the part of the essay where I directly contradict myself. Because my mysterious twitter user was entirely correct. While kpop does clearly draw inspiration from western pop, rock, hip hop, and R&B, if that was all it did, why did One Direction sound so different from Shinee? In fact, there's only one western pop group I can say even comes close to the kpop sounds of that era: N*SYNC.
Kpop is a genre, however it is not because they (sometimes) sing in Korean. Like every other genre, it is defined by the actual music.
One of the main reasons I delayed writing this essay was because my initial thoughts were driven by haterism. Even I find myself insufferable as fuck when I'm being bitter hater, so I try to discourage these tendencies within myself. Fortunately, in between then and now, a group I adore dropped an album illustrating my point exactly.
Just B's "Chest" and the album "Just Odd" were on my Top of 2025 lists. However by their own admission, "Chest" was them bringing hyperpop into the kpop scene. Their follow up title, "True Heart" was similarly hyper pop. Fantastic songs, but not kpop.
While they seem to have gone out of vogue, I can't be the only one who remembers press releases describing the songs to be released. They'd say things like "R&B ballad that expresses the true feelings of the members" and other very corny things. It seems only the fans were unaware that not every pop song that came out of Korea was kpop-the-genre.
So what is kpop music?
What drew me in, aside from WayV's princess party, was kpop's ability to combine genres in unexpected, new ways in a single song, while also playing fast and loose with song structure.
Before 2020, I had never heard anything like "Lucifer" or "I Got a Boy". It's easy to say "Well, that's just SM" but that's reductive. Lee Soo Man was a pioneer in the genre, true, but these traits show up across the industry, in 2NE1, Big Bang, Oh My Girl, EXID, and in more contemporary groups like i-dle, Dreamcatcher, NMIXX and, yes, Just B.
Just B's "K-pop" (the album) is truly an evolutionary homage to this sound. It could have been penned by GD himself, if not for the shades of hyperpop and undeniable Just B indie attitude woven throughout.
If this is the sound you like—kpop as a blender, far more experimental than the pop that charts in the US and UK—it isn't strange to find yourself divorced from the current crop of kpop darlings. There has been an industry-wide shift to chasing global (read: American) dollars and a shift from traditional promotion towards hoping to go viral on tiktok. Whether or not these are the decisions of A&R teams or edicts handed down by CEOs, the elements of kpop (the genre) have been almost wholly abandoned in 5th gen. Many of the darlings of the charts make straight bubblegum pop or songs that wouldn't stand out on a Travis Scott album. This doesn't make them bad songs, but it's ludicrous to pretend they're the same genre as "Sticker".
Yes, you can still find some amazing genre-bending bangers, like Close Your Eyes' "Open Your Eyes" and All Hours' "Dang Dang" but they have become rare. Like everything, kpop will continue moving forward whether it wants to or not, and as kpop-the-genre fades into the background, most of what we now associate as its hallmarks are actually kpop-the-industry standards and practices.
The Cannibalism of Perfection
What the heck does any of this have to do with New Jeans? Well, I can't think of a better example of a group exposing the realities of kpop (the industry) since TVXQ.
These were very young girls who were coerced into signing contracts that shocked even American record execs working in the 1970s, who were beaten down, shunned, told to have plastic surgery, and still managed to become global sensations, all while singing about their pussies. At 14. And yes. That is what "Cookie" is about.
They had the perfect, innocent looks to bait the pedophiles and mom-fans, the creative direction of the canny Min Hee Jin who saw a gap in the market to bring parasocialism to an even younger crowd, all backed by the money and machinery of HYBE.
And the worst thing is that kpop fans haven't seemed to learn shit all from the whole fiasco.
Lee Soo Man's new A20 groups are the direct result of an industry that has only became more exploitative. I genuinely believe it should be a crime to debut 13-year-olds.
Not a single actor, idol, singer, or other entertainer who worked on a professional level as a child says it was good for them. In fact, Taliesin Jaffe and Ashley Johnson, now of Critical Role fame, have an entire podcast about their fucked-up childhoods as kid TV stars. In one episode, Ashley recalls how she was almost kidnapped on set by a stalker fan.
We already know kpop has a sasaeng problem, but it's totally fine to put 13-year-olds in danger because the music's good, right?
Idols work as hard as professional athletes. According to the New York Times article, pre-debut, when some of them were as young as 12, New Jeans was practicing until 2 AM. Should any 12-year-old be going to school during the day, and then dancing without breaks until the early morning? Not only can this cause massive psychological damage, but it also literally changes how your body grows. SNSD have talked about how they didn't get their periods until years after their non-idol peers.
But who cares because look at them dance!
No one wants to confront the reality written so clearly in the New Jeans contract: it is preferable to debut children because they don't have the means to protect themselves. And any parent that would willingly put their child in that situation clearly does not care about protecting them either.
A20 is the inevitable conclusion of kpop-the-industry. Just like every other capitalist endeavor, it must extract greater and greater profit to satisfy the rich, and the best way to do this is by increasing the exploitation of the laborers and jacking up the prices on the consumers.
Late-Stage Kpop
So, that was bleak and I don't like ending on a down note. However we can't get from point A to point B if we refuse to acknowledge where point A actually is.
It is really down to the individual fan to decide how they want to react to this information. Much like some have refused to put down Harry Potter because it meant so much to them as children, even though any money spent on the HP empire goes to fund anti-trans legislation, some kpop fans simply will not give a shit if buying albums and merch and fancalls for a group hurts the very people they claim to support.
I strongly believe we owe responsibilities to others, and in the dynamic of fan-versus-corporation, that responsibility looks very different than individual-to-community. It is your responsibility to choose where you spend your entertainment dollars. I mentioned at the beginning of this essay that WayV stole my heart. They broke it, too, with the news that YangYang directly profits from Israel's genocide in Gaza through owning shares in his family company.
I had to choose. What was more important to me: a group that brought me so much happiness or standing in solidarity with Palestine?
It is good to ask yourselves these questions, even if it means you are too sad to listen to a discography you loved. It's not like WayV is the only kpop group I enjoy. I've found new ones, and other things that bring me joy beside. And I feel peace, because I don't have the guilt weighing on my conscience.
Let me assure you, that as a millennial, I've watched many industries die, yet art always lives on.





